Betting On Indianapolis Colts To Win The Super Bowl

The Indianapolis Colts

Betting On the Indianapolis Colts to win the Super Bowl should be considered a solid bet to make. The Colts have found great success over the years as they have added to their 29 playoff appearances, 16 division championships, seven conference championships and two Super Bowl Championships. They seem to have gotten back to their Super Bowl contending form as of late and could be in line to surprise some bettors. They have been a middle of the field team in recent years with +2500 odds in two of the last three seasons which could mean a playoff run is coming.

With Matt Ryan now being under center behind arguably one of the best offensive lines in the NFL, their chemistry could come into play in defending the Colts Super Bowl 57 odds. The team has also gotten a nice boost from Jonathan Taylor as he continues to emerge as one of the leagues premier running backs. The defense has also stood its ground as well.

When betting on the Indianapolis Colts, bettors will come across many different odds. NFL sportsbooks offer Super Bowl odds on the Colts as well as their odds to win the AFC Championship and win the AFC South division as well. Aside from the Colts futures odds are also Colts player prop bets as well. This page will also run-down the Colts playoff history.

Colts Playoff Record By Round

  • Overall: 23-25
  • Wild Card: 7-7
  • Divisional Round: 8-11
  • Conference Championship: 4-4
  • Super Bowl: 2-2

Indianapolis Colts Playoff History

Playoff Appearances
1958, 1959, 1964, 1965, 1968, 1970, 1971, 1975, 1976, 1977, 1987, 1995, 1996, 1999, 2000, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2018, 2020
Division Championships
1968, 1970, 1975, 1976, 1977, 1987, 1999, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009, 2010, 2013, 2014
Conference Championships
1958, 1959, 1964, 1968, 1970, 2006, 2009
Super Bowl Victories
1972 (VII), 1973 (VIII)
Super Bowl Losses
1969 (III), 2010 (XLIV)
Super Bowl Winning Quarterbacks
Earl Morrall, Peyton Manning
Super Bowl Winning Coaches
Don McCafferty, Tony Dungy
Super Bowl MVPs
Peyton Manning
Best Sites for Betting on the Super Bowl
Bovada Sportsbook
  • 50%
  • up to
  • $250
BetOnline Sportsbook
  • 50%
  • up to
  • $1,000
MyBookie Sportsbook
  • 250%
  • up to
  • $1,000
Xbet Sportsbook
  • 100%
  • up to
  • $300
Sportsbetting Sportsbook
  • 50%
  • up to
  • $1,000

What Are Indianapolis Colts Odds To Win The Super Bowl?

The Colts did make some valuable moves in the offseason and through the draft that bolstered their Super Bowl 57 odds. They moved on from Carson Wentz and replaced him with Matt Ryan who had +1000 odds to be their next QB and completely armed their defensive unit with the addition of Stephon Gilmore, Rodney McLeod, and Yannick Ngakoue. They also added offensive depth through the draft in receiver Alec Pierce, tight end Jelani Woods, and OT Bernhard Raimann. Their Super Bowl odds were sitting down towards +3000 before coming way up closer to +2000 after all was said and done in the offseason.

What Are the Indianapolis Colts Odds To Win The AFC Championship?

Following the significant changes to their roster, they also saw their odds to win the AFC come up a bit from +1400. Now, they would still need to get their chemistry going on both sides of the ball, but with a vet in Matt Ryan leading the way under center, and arguably the top running back in the NFL in Jonathan Taylor, their odds could be offering some tremendous value right now. This is now the third straight season where they have opened with preseason AFC Championship odds under +2000.

What Are The Indianapolis Colts Odds To Win The AFC South?

The Colts might have taken over the AFC South division this offseason being that all of their division rivals either took a step back or are still nowhere near contending. The Jaguars and Texans are coming off of top draft picks going towards their rebuilds while the Titans just shipped off their best receiver in AJ Brown. That leaves Indy as possibly the lone contender of the division. Despite not winning a division title since 2014 when they were -175 favorites, they’ve been between +100 and +200 in the last three years.

2023 Indianapolis Colts Betting Odds

Indianapolis Colts ATS Betting History

  • 2021: 10-7
  • 2020: 9-8
  • 2019: 7-7-2
  • 2018: 9-8-1
  • 2017: 8-8
  • 2016: 7-8-1

Indianapolis Colts Over/Under Betting History

  • 2021: 8-9
  • 2020: 10-7
  • 2019: 9-7
  • 2018: 8-10
  • 2017: 6-10
  • 2016: 9-7

Indianapolis Colts Vs. Jacksonville Jaguars Week 2

The Colts are looking to notch their first win in Week 2 against the Jacksonville Jaguars after tying in Week 1 with the Houston Texans. Oddsmakers have given the Colts the magic number on the spread while being on the road. In the 20 games, they’ve been favored between 2-3 points on the road, they are a whopping 20-0 SU and 17-2-1 ATS. Houston, on the other hand, has gone 1-5 in their last six straight up as a 2–3-point home underdog and 2-3 ATS.

Indianapolis Colts Odds Versus The Jacksonville Jaguars

Colts Week 2 Betting Trends

  • Colts are 5-0 ATS in last five Week 2 games.
  • Colts have gone 6-2 against the spread in last 8 road games overall.
  • Under in points in 4-0 in last four divisional games.
  • Under is 6-0 in last six games going in as favorites.

Betting On The Colts In Indiana

The best option for Colts betting is going to be international sportsbooks like Bovada and BetOnline. These sportsbooks are not located inside Indiana, which means they don’t have issues with hometown bias, so Colts’ odds are often fairer at these international books. In terms of in-state betting, Indianapolis itself features an OTB sportsbook at the Winner’s Circle Pub, and there are casinos that offer sports betting as well as in-state sports betting apps.

Indianapolis Sportsbooks And Casino Partners

Sportsbook Casino Partner
Bally Bet Bally's Evansville
Barstool Sportsbook Hollywood Casino Lawrenceburg
BetMGM Belterra Casino
BetRivers French Lick Resort
Betway Sportsbook Belterra Casino
Caesars Sportsbook Horseshoe Casino Hammond
DraftKings Sportsbook Ameristar Casino East Chicago
FanDuel Sportsbook Blue Chip Casino
PointsBet Hollywood Casino Lawrenceburg
SBK Sportsbook Rising Star Casino Resort
TheScore Bet Ameristar Casino East Chicago
Unibet Sportsbook Horseshoe Casino Hammond
WynnBet Rising Star Casino Resort
Mobile Betting On The Indianapolis Colts

Colts fans and bettors are some of the most loyal across the entire NFL. That said alone, any chance that they get to bet on the Colts they will and that is where mobile betting comes into play. Colts bettors can bet on any odds that come to mind from wherever they are. Taking it one step further, bettors can also take advantage of any promotions that online sportsbooks might offer right from your phone as well.

2023 Colts Player Props

Super Bowl Betting Props

If there is one thing that the Colts are nothing shy of, it is explosiveness and with the addition of a veteran QB under center in Matt Ryan, they could blow the roof off of Lucas Oil Stadium. In addition to Matty Ice, Jonathan Taylor, the league leader in rushing yards and touchdowns, leads the backfield, while a young up-and-coming receiver in Michael Pittman Jr. is locked in at WR1. With so much talent to offer, oddsmakers were not shy of listing player props for them.

Colts Player Props

  • Offensive Player Of The Year: Jonathan Taylor +850
  • Regular Season MVP: Matt Ryan +3500, Jonathan Taylor +5000
  • Most Passing Touchdowns: Matt Ryan +4000
  • Most Passing Yards: Matt Ryan +2500
  • Most Receiving Touchdowns: Michael Pittman Jr. +2500
  • Most Receiving Yards: Michael Pittman Jr. +5000
  • Most Rushing Yards: Jonathan Taylor +600
  • Most Rushing Touchdowns: Jonathan Taylor +450 (Favorite)

Matt Ryan’s odds for most passing yards should not be ignored and he has his top-ranked offensive line to thank for that. This front seven is easily Ryan’s best that he has had in his career meaning he will have all the time in the world to find the open receiver. He even has the sixth easiest schedule for a QB in the upcoming season as well.

Looking at Jonathan Taylor, you should get in on his favored odds to lead the league in touchdowns while you still can. Taylor led the league last year with 18 and similar to Ryan, he can thank the offensive line. Also, the Colts gameplan heavily favored him whenever they were in the redzone as he got 80.58% of the touches inside of the 20 which not only led the team, but led the league as well. More than half of his scores came in the redzone as well with 11.

Betting On Indianapolis Colts Team Props

Super Bowl Betting Props

One of the great things about team props for the Indianapolis Colts is that there are so many to choose from. Whether it’s their projected total wins, odds to make the playoffs, odds to lead the league in points, or one of the many others, they will be available to you all throughout the season.

Indianapolis Colts Win Total

  • Over 10 -145
  • Under 10 +110

Indianapolis Colts Odds To Make The Playoffs

  • Yes -185
  • No +140

Other Indianapolis Colts Odds

  • Record Most QB Sacks: +3000
  • Score Most Points: +2000
  • Most Wins: +1800

Two of their team props that stand ahead of the rest are their odds to make the playoffs and their odds to lead the league in sacks as a team. Starting with their playoff odds, they are in a great spot in terms of their roster with a veteran QB leading the way in Matt Ryan and arguably the best running back in the league, Jonathan Taylor. Going based on trends though, dating back to 2017, they’ve made the playoffs every other season and with them missing last season, on paper, they are scheduled to make it again this year.

Looking at their odds to lead the NFL in sacks, they have one of the best defensive lines in the league. It consists of DeForest Buckner, Shaquille Leonard, newly acquired Yannick Ngakoue, and Kwity Paye. While last season was a huge step back, this unit has the potential to be the best in the league. Fortunately for them though, their schedule is “defensive line friendly” this season as they have eight matchups against teams ranked in the bottom ten worst offensive lines in the 2022-23 season.

Indianapolis Colts Odds History

Year: Super Bowl Odds: AFC Odds: AFC South Odds: Odds To Make Playoffs:
2022 +2500 +1400 +125 -165 (TBD)
2021 +3500 +1800 +150 -120 (Miss)
2020 +2500 +1200 +110 -175 (Make)
2019 +8000 +4000 +350 +200 (Miss)
2018 +5000 +2500 +400 +240 (Make)
2017 +10000 +5000 +600 +350 (Miss)
2016 +2000 +1000 +200 -105 (Miss)
2015 +800 +3000 -550 -675 (Miss)
2014 +2200 +900 -175 -225 (Make)
2013 +3500 +1400 +240 +160 (Make)

Indianapolis Colts Playoff History

The Indianapolis Colts found playoff success early on in their existence in the league since they were founded in 1953. They have seen 28 different playoff berths which include 16 division championships, 7 conference champions and 2 Super Bowl victories. Just four of their playoff appearance came in the pre-Super Bowl era which started in 1966.

Colts Playoff Appearances

The Colts' first playoff appearances came shortly after they became an official team in 1958 again in 1959 under coach Weeb Ewbank. They won 3 more in the 60s under the legendary Don Shula who won in 1964-1965 and again in 1868. From 1970 to 2000 they did not find as much success as they only saw 10 playoff berths in those 30 years with four in the 70s, 1 in the 80s and four in the 90s and the year 2000. They found more success after the year 2000 as they have seen 13 playoff appearances with their last one coming in 2018 under coach Frank Reich.

Colts Division Championship

Of the Colts 28 playoff appearances, they have been able to reel in 16 division championships with their first one coming in 1968 under the great Don Shula. Their next two came in the 70s in 1970 and 1975 under both Don McCafferty and Howard Schnellenberger. They saw just two more in the 80s and 90s in 1987 under Ted Marchibroda and in 1999 under with Jim Mora. From the 2000s until the present day, the Colts took off running as they have won 9 division titles since then with five different coaches including Tony Dungy, Jim Caldwell and Chuck Pagano.

Colts Conference Championship

With their many years of playoff experience, they have not been able to convert many of them into conference championship as they have only racked up 7 of them. From 1958 to 1970 they won the majority of them as they won five with their first and second ones coming in 1958 and 1959 under Weeb Ewbank with Johnny Unitas under center. They did not win their next one until 1964 then again in 1968 and again in 1970 all under Don Shula. Their most recent ones came in 2006 and 2009 under Tony Dungy and Jim Caldwell.

Colts Super Bowl Victories

The Colts have two Super Bowl victories on their resume which includes a Super Bowl win in 1972 for Super Bowl VII and again in 2007 for Super Bowl XLI with coaches Don McCafferty and Tony Dungy calling plays.

Starting in 1972 with Super Bowl VII where the then Baltimore Colts defeated the Dallas Cowboys with a final score of 16-13. The Colts were able to just barely cover the spread as they went into the game seen as 2.5-point favorites and covered as they won by three points. The Super Bowl MVP of the game was Chuck Howley as he had two interceptions for 22 return yards.

Moving on to their most recent Super Bowl in 2007 for Super Bowl XLI, they took on and defeated the Chicago Bears with a final score of 29-17. The Colts had no problems with the spread here as they went into the game as 6.5-point favorites and covered it with ease as they won by 12 -points. The great Peyton Manning was named the Super Bowl MVP after throwing for 247 yards and a touchdown.

2014 AFC Wild Card: Colts Complete 28-Point Comeback Against Chiefs

The largest Colts playoff comeback was one of the biggest comebacks in the history of the league, when the Colts completed a 28 point comeback against the Kansas City Chiefs during the 2014 AFC Wild Card game. The Chiefs took a 38-10 lead on an Alex Smith passing touchdown early in the third quarter. A 10 yard rush from Colts’ running back Donald Brown began a run that saw the Colts outscore the Chiefs 35-6 for the remainder of the game. The massive comeback culminated in a 64 yard touchdown pass from Andrew Luck to T.Y. Hilton, putting the Colts ahead 45-44 with 4:21 remaining in the game. The Colts defense held the lead, resulting in a whopping 28 point comeback - the largest in Colts history and one of the largest in the history of the league.